top of page

Why the three-way summit in China is no new Yalta

Writer: Armin Sijamić
Armin Sijamić
3h
7 min read

On Wednesday and Thursday the world's eyes were on Shenzhen, a Chinese city where Xi Jinping, China's president, was joined, among others, by his American and Russian counterparts, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin.

Three presidents at the Shenzhen summit.
Three presidents at the Shenzhen summit.

Bilateral meetings, followed by the first-ever three-way meeting of the trio, led many to conclude that the future of the world would be settled in two days. In short, the three presidents would run the world by carving it into spheres of influence.


Such expectations pushed into the background the reason Mr Trump and Mr Putin had come to China in the first place: the summit of Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC). A few days earlier, the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) had held its own summit in the Philippines, where the American president was the main attraction.


Today's meeting of the presidents of the world's three most powerful countries prompted many comparisons with the Yalta conference in Crimea. There, from February 4th to 11th 1945, Josef Stalin, the Soviet leader, Franklin D. Roosevelt, the American president, and Winston Churchill, Britain's prime minister, drew the political map of an emerging world while they waited for the certain collapse of Nazi Germany and its allies. That meeting produced a world that lasted from 1945 until the fall of the Soviet Union. It survives still, through the political and economic institutions that shape it and give the West primacy over the rest of the world.


The road to China


Alarm bells rang across Europe, where many do not trust Mr Trump. Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukraine's president, said nothing would be resolved in China without Ukraine. On the day of the Shenzhen summit, representatives of Europe's biggest powers (Germany, France, and Britain, along with some 40 other countries in the "coalition of the willing" that helps Ukraine) gathered in Berlin to say that they would keep supporting Kyiv.


Ukraine was, without doubt, one of the two main topics of the talks in China. The other was Iran and the parts of the Middle East where Tehran has decisive or significant influence. Through their resistance, two regional powers, Ukraine and Iran, have spoiled the plans of two great powers: Russia and the world's greatest, America. A third topic, of particular interest to Mr Trump and Mr Xi, was artificial intelligence, since America and China are the only serious contenders in that race.


Russia is represented by a president wanted by the International Criminal Court (ICC) for war crimes in Ukraine. It took the summit more seriously than China or America did. For weeks, Russian media and officials prepared the ground by talking of a "new security architecture" in Eurasia, and insisted that in Ukraine, they had the same intentions as America.


The Ukrainians know that Mr Putin and the Russians play with symbols, an important element of diplomacy and of Russian propaganda, which is often effective. On Wednesday and Thursday they replied, probably with help from their Western allies, by attacking the bridge that links occupied Crimea to Russia. Two days of strikes put the bridge, which Mr Putin opened and described as his favourite, out of action. The Ukrainians used aerial and naval drones and long-range missiles. The message to Mr Putin, and to his interlocutors, was that Ukraine sees its Crimea, where Yalta lies, differently, and that it will not accept whatever is served up to it.


The Iranians and their allies, too, had a message for America and for their Russian and Chinese partners. This week, they again targeted some American military installations. Iraq's Shia militias mobilised to reject a demand from parts of the government in Baghdad that they disarm under an arrangement with Washington. Yemen's Houthis, meanwhile, advanced to the outskirts of Aden, leaving the strategically vital Bab al-Mandab strait deep inside their territory.


Mr Xi, whose country is not at war, held the most comfortable position at the summit. He did everything to make Mr Trump feel at ease in China. The welcome at the airport, which the Chinese president attended in person, included hundreds of children waving Chinese and American flags and shouting "welcome" in Mandarin.


Almost five years of Russian aggression against Ukraine, and Russia's resulting status as unwelcome in much of the world, have meanwhile allowed Beijing, after decades in a subordinate position, to present itself as Moscow's senior partner. Mr Putin was met at the airport by Cai Qi, the head of the Chinese president's office and the fifth-ranking official in the hierarchy of the Chinese Communist Party.


Mr Xi thus returned the warm welcome he had received in Washington at the end of September. This meeting between the two men, too, was dominated by the same subject: artificial intelligence (AI).


AI, or rather the production and sale of chips, has long been the subject of negotiations between Washington and Beijing. In the run-up to the Shenzhen summit, Jensen Huang was removed as head of Nvidia, the giant of the chip and AI industry. His departure touches the most sensitive secrets of the current American administration. American media and journalists have spent days trying to discover the real reasons why a man Mr Trump trusted was pushed out.


A world very different from 1945


Beyond these topics, the three presidents also set themselves the task of dealing with nuclear weapons. Mr Trump has insisted, and Mr Putin has not refused in the past, that the two biggest nuclear powers should work to reduce their arsenals. China, which lags far behind them in this field, has refused for reasons that are not entirely clear, perhaps only so that it has something to offer as a compromise in a strategic bargain. It is on this question that the three-way meeting may have yielded the most. On everything else, America, China, and Russia remain far apart.


After the meeting, which lasted about 80 minutes, Mr Putin and the Russian side showed the most satisfaction. Whatever happened at the summit, that reaction was to be expected. It repairs his damaged image at home and abroad and lends him legitimacy to decide the fate of other countries. Before the meeting began, Yuri Ushakov, his aide, said it would be "a spectacle that will overshadow everything else". The summit may well have overshadowed much in Russia, but what it will change in substance is another question.


In Mr Trump's telling, nothing he does can be anything other than excellent. Like Mr Putin, he needs a win in foreign policy for domestic purposes, especially after his heavy defeat in the recent elections. He blames that defeat on the war against Iran and on the (un)popularity of Israel, to which the American president is so devoted.


The Chinese side prepared the public for great things. On Monday, Mao Ning, a spokeswoman for China's foreign ministry, ascribed "revolutionary significance" to the three-way summit.


But Mr Trump often fails to deliver what he signs, agrees to, or promises. Recall his meeting with Mr Putin in Alaska, or what JD Vance, his vice-president, agreed with the Iranian side at talks in Pakistan. His ambivalence towards Ukraine and Europe also shows how hard the current American president finds it to consolidate power at home and to stick to his commitments.


All this suggests that today's world is not the world of 1945. Nor are the men at the table in Shenzhen on the same side, and they have no common enemy, as the Allies did in the Second World War. Still, two of the three will celebrate the outcome of this meeting as revolutionary, because in one sense it is. Unlike at Yalta, two enemies of the West sat at the table with an American president who is quarrelling even with his closest allies. Moscow and Beijing read this as an important victory, even if nothing discussed in Shenzhen is ever realised. It fits what, since the collapse of the Soviet Union, they have called a multipolar world: in this case, a tripolar one, which would follow the bipolar and unipolar orders.


Hence the meeting mattered more to China and Russia than to Mr Trump. Beijing understands that many countries today refuse to side with only one camp, something Chinese policy has encouraged for decades, and which, in 1945, was almost impossible. For Moscow, it is now almost existentially important to win "crumbs" in Eastern Europe compared with what it won at Yalta. Washington under Mr Trump, meanwhile, keeps making U-turns and stunts that neither its allies nor its enemies can accept.


Little on paper, a lot at stake for the West


The summit ended with a joint statement. It calls for reform of the United Nations; the three countries plan to increase production of oil products; they want to curb the work of the court that has issued a warrant for Mr Putin; and they accept a dialogue on reducing the risks of the use and spread of nuclear weapons.


If that is all that was agreed, it is little for a summit heralded as epoch-making. It is especially little for Mr Trump, America, and the West, which will gain nothing substantial from it, except perhaps new divisions and quarrels among allies.


First, neither UN reform nor nuclear arms control can be achieved without France and Britain, both permanent members of the UN Security Council and both nuclear powers. India, the Muslim-majority countries, Africa, and Latin America will surely also want a say in reforming the organisation. Second, restricting the ICC means abandoning what the three supposedly stand for when they speak of world peace. Third, those who have been a theatre of war since February, when Mr Trump and Israel attacked Iran, will have something to say about oil production.


Finally, the absence from the conclusions of any mention of the problems in relations between America, China, and Russia suggests that much will be attributed to this summit, in the media and elsewhere, by way of free interpretation.


For China and Russia, though, it is a great success that at a table which presumes to shape the world's fate, they faced only America, and a president who calls "friends" the heads of states that American strategy documents label enemies and rivals, while he pushes away those who have been loyal to Washington for decades.



The article was previously published on nap.ba



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page